Sauce

How to make gravy without drippings, using butter and broth

How to make gravy without drippings, using butter and broth. Extension ratios, how to get flavor without the roasting pan, and how long it keeps.

Published

01

What

Melt butter (or another fat) in a saucepan, whisk in flour, then whisk in hot broth. Iowa State Extension’s ratio is 2 tablespoons fat, 2 tablespoons flour and 1 cup of liquid for each cup of gravy, doubled or tripled as needed. Simmer until it coats a spoon. You don’t need drippings for this to work; you do need to build flavor another way (see below).

If you do have a roasting pan of fond, use it: how to make gravy starts by deglazing those brown bits, and that’s still the most flavorful path. This page is for when you don’t.

02

Why (ELI5)

ELI5

Gravy is fat, a thickener, and liquid, heated until the starch gelatinizes (University of Wyoming Extension). The fat doesn’t have to come from a roasting pan: Iowa State University Extension says that if there isn’t enough drippings fat, you can use butter, oil, margarine or another fat, and that some gravies are made with broth only. Mississippi State University Extension’s holiday gravy starts the same way, with margarine or butter and low-sodium chicken or turkey broth.

03

How

Butter, flour and broth, step by step

  1. 01Warm the fat in a saucepan over medium heat. Iowa State lists butter, coconut oil, vegetable oil, olive oil, margarine or bacon fat; Mississippi State uses margarine, butter or drippings, melted over low heat.
  2. 02Whisk in the flour. Iowa State whisks equal parts fat and flour (2 tablespoons of each per cup of liquid) and lets the mix bubble and brown slightly. For how a roux works, and why a darker one thickens less, see how to make a roux.
  3. 03Add the liquid slowly, whisking the whole time. Iowa State uses defatted drippings, a mix of drippings and broth, or other liquid, and whisks vigorously so the roux dissolves and doesn’t lump. For this no-drippings method, use hot broth: 1 cup of liquid per 2 tablespoons of fat and flour, or homemade turkey stock. Wyoming Extension also allows canned broth or stock. Mississippi State University Extension likewise starts gravy with butter or margarine and low-sodium chicken or turkey broth, with drippings optional.
  4. 04Bring it to a boil, then simmer. Iowa State simmers gently until it’s slightly thick, then about 10 minutes more, adding liquid if it gets too thick. Mississippi State cooks 5 to 10 minutes over low heat.
  5. 05Taste, then season. Iowa State: salt, pepper, and herbs such as sage or thyme, going lightly on the salt if the broth is already salted.

How to get flavor without the pan

Wyoming Extension says you can cook aromatics in the hot fat before the flour goes in: sweet onions and garlic, or mushrooms and herbs, until they’ve softened. It isn’t required, but it’s the chance to put flavor in when you have no fond. Iowa State’s rescue for bland gravy is the same idea: a little more salt or herbs, a drop or two of soy sauce, or sautéed onions or mushrooms.

For a deeper broth, University of Maine Extension browns the turkey neck (the one in the cavity) with carrot, celery and onion, simmering it in low-sodium stock, broth or water until the liquid reduces by a third, then strains it and builds the gravy from that liquid and a butter-and-flour roux. Drippings, if you have them later, are optional at the end. That neck-and-vegetable step is a short version of turkey stock.

Flour or cornstarch

This page uses a flour roux, which Wyoming Extension says reheats better. If you can’t use flour, Iowa State points to cornstarch or potato starch, and says to skip arrowroot and tapioca because they can go stringy in gravy. Ratios, the look of each, and how to mix a slurry: how to make gravy and how to thicken a sauce.

Make it ahead, and how long it keeps

Iowa State: gravy is perishable. Discard it after more than 2 hours at room temperature (the same 2-hour rule as FSIS). In an airtight container it keeps 2 days in the fridge, or about 3 months in the freezer for best quality; Iowa State says it stays safe longer than that. When you reheat it, Iowa State brings it to a slow rolling boil, stirring so it doesn’t scorch. FSIS says the same: sauces, soups and gravies go to a rolling boil.

Those 2 days match the 1-to-2-day fridge window on the Thanksgiving make-ahead timeline (Illinois Extension and SDSU Extension). Tuesday is the earliest you can make it for Thursday dinner.

04

Common mistakes

Lumpy: Iowa State blends it smooth. Wyoming Extension, on the live gravy page, also strains it. Too thick: Iowa State adds drippings, broth, water or orange juice. Too thin: Iowa State whisks in a flour-and-water slurry and brings it to a boil, or adds a small equal-parts butter-and-flour roux. Bland: more salt or herbs, a drop or two of soy sauce, or sautéed onions or mushrooms (Iowa State). Salty broth: go light on the salt, and taste as you go (Iowa State).

Sources